Tuesday, March 17, 2009

The Devil is a Kid's Best Friend

When looking at the original text by the Grimm Brothers, you can already tell it's geared towards a child audience.  The devil is stupid, and could easily be outsmarted by any of the children imagining this story.  In fact, I see almost no way at all that the film version could not be geared towards children when the original text, too, scolds the devil and puts him in a light that is not only humorous, but overpowered.  In both versions, the devil does have some sort of superior.  This implies that he can be tamed, like a pet, like a fool, and that to children indicates that they too are superior to him.  The devil in the film is also ridiculously painted and costumed; children respond powerfully to visuals.  They know that he looks ridiculous; therefore, he is.  

The Devil for Children

The DEFA version of “The Devil’s Three Golden Hairs” is definitely geared towards a child audience. This film seems like it is meant for families with elementary school aged children because of the way the devil is made into a fool. Jacob pretends to be the devil’s wife and dances with him then scolds him and sends him to bed; that is the kind of humor that young children find funny. Fear of the devil and death is overlooked and made fun of in this film. The devil is almost like a child in that his wife makes him supper and then sends him to bed for being naughty. That is something children can relate to and they will find it amusing that this grown man, who is supposed to be powerful and fearsome, is being treated as a child. There are a number of other parts in the film that were put in specifically to make children laugh. For instance, Jacob runs off into the woods after seeing a mouse or when the devil becoming huge after eating and drinking so much at the wedding.

It’s interesting how the good mother figure of the devil’s grandmother is not in the film, his wife is only mentioned. It’s as if the filmmakers are saying that the actual presence of a mother figure is not important, only the acknowledgement of her existence is significant to the story.

No Golden Globes for Golden Hairs

A lot of things happened in 1977. Annie Hall came out and made men's wear for women popular(here). The historical mini-series Roots came out too(here). The last Star Wars movie came out (the "second trilogy" does not count)(here). For kid's the movie "Pete's Dragon" came out (here). The Muppet Show was in its second season(here). And in East Germany DEFA released 'The Devil's Three Golden Hairs."

Guess which one was the worst. I was surprised while first watching the film that it had been made later than Schneewittchen. Perhaps this is due to what seems to be some location shooting and its effort to use "special effects." The whole thing seemed somewhat shoddy. I suppose it could be given a break since it was a made for tv movie, but at the same point, a bit of effort could have been made. I could be picking on it a bit hard.

The story seemed to be trying to make too many points for children. An obvious first point is that drinking is BAD. The boy main character takes one sip of the king's liquor, and is put all out of sorts as seen by the double vision and dizzying camera effects. The king is constantly drinking from his flask, he is an obvious alcoholic. His character is also the worst one, therefore it takes no fool to see the 'subtle' message.

I thought it was funny that a big part of the movie was questioning the leader. They levy tax, and no one believes the king is telling the truth about robbers. In fact, the king's tax collector, once he does finally happen upon the robber's den, is surprised that one even exists, saying "but there Are No Robbers!" For East Germany, I would think that this would go against their system. Questioning what the government tells you does not seem like the best idea to give to children in the GDR.

I suppose in the end, this movie left me a bit confused. Why did he go to such trouble to get the hairs, if in the end he would give them back to the devil? What was the point of him being afraid of mice, and then claiming to not be in the end, I still think he was, the devil did not test him twice. Why did only the leader of the robbers on the boat set himself free? Did the other robbers get to leave later? I don't know. DEFA could have handled this better, I am not sure exactly how this fairy tale jived with their ideals, since I saw what I think were a few jarring subplots.

Assignment: 17 March 2009

This week we are going by the normal schedule, so please post by Tuesday at midnight and leave two comments by Wednesday night.

Prompt: Respond to the film “The Devil’s Three Golden Hairs” (DEFA). You may wish to consider one (or more) of the following:
  • Target audience
  • How it uses the medium specifically in order to tell its version of the story
  • Comparison to the DEFA version of “Snow White”

Wednesday, March 11, 2009

I was going to write a whole post about how the film is different from the original story because of the fact that Cocteau has turned it into an opera, and how much of it sounds like Phillip Glass. However, after researching the movie, I see that I have accidentally watched a re-dubbed operatic version actually composed by Phillip Glass, so I'm going to talk about it anyway!
Since this is the only version I saw, I want to talk about what making this film an opera did to the story. Glass' use of repetition and building chord structures in all of his compositions creates an other worldly feel that allows the listener to get lost in the music. Pairing his style with a fairy tale has created an interesting result because along with the surrealist style that Cocteau employs, the film really creates a fairy tale world unlike anything on the page in Beaumont's version is able to do. Not only does the music create that fairy tale feel, but it also dramatizes the story intensely. Hearing the characters sing passionately to each other instead of simply speaking takes the emotions involved in the story to new heights. We feel for the characters as they sing with more passion and emotion. Similarly, since there is no diegetic sound in this version of the film, we take all of our cures from the music itself. As the music crescendos, we are swept away with the characters into whatever is happening. In a way, this operatic fairy tale does the best job out of any media we have been exposed to so far of truely immersing us into the world in which the story takes place, and making us truely care about the outcome of its characters.

Tuesday, March 10, 2009

Addition of Avenant

One thing that stood out to me the most in Cocteau’s “La Belle et La Bête” is the character of Avenant is added. He is not in De Beaumont’s version of “Beauty and the Beast.” In De Beaumont’s version, Beauty has two sisters and three brothers, and then in the film she has two sisters, one brother, and Avenant, her brother’s friend. Avenant is like Gaston in Disney’s film; he is the arrogant, handsome man who wants to marry Beauty.

It is interesting how when Beauty tells the Beast that Avenant had proposed to her the Beast gets upset and runs off. I thought he went to kill Avenant because he comes back to the castle covered in blood, but then we see Avenant playing chess a few moments later. The Beast acted as if he recognized the name, but that whole scene doesn’t seem to be important to the story as it progresses since Avenant and the Beast never interact.

Also, the brother and Avenant are lazy and act more like the two sisters in the film than the brothers do in the written tale. Beauty’s brother and Avenant play major roles in the decisions made to get Beauty to stay so that they can steal the Beast’s treasures. However, in the written version, the three brothers do not try to keep Beauty away from the Beast. Other than these changes I felt that the film stays fairly true to De Beaumont’s version. Of course, Magnificent, the Beast’s horse, was added, as well as the pavilion full of treasures and a few other changes.

Madam Beaumont’s version of ‘Beauty and the Beast’ vs. Cocteau's "La Belle et la Bête"

I agree with Moriah that that was the most striking change from the two versions of Madam Beaumont’s version of ‘Beauty and the Beast’ and Cocteau's "La Belle et la Bête". However, there were several other changes in the movie than the text version of the fairytale- such as the Beast giving Belle the key to his secret pavilion where all of his most sacred treasures laid. In giving her that key it was symbolizing his complete trust in Belle that she will keep her promise and return to the castle after a week of being with her father. Thus there was another change in which her siblings and her brother’s friend tries to get Belle to reveal the secret of getting to the Beast’s castle and getting the key from her. In the movie, the Beast sends a horse to take Belle back to the castle, but the brother and his friend gets on the horse instead, and the sisters leave the mirror for Belle. She is then able to see that the Beast is really sad and thus she decides to return to him. Also, in the movie, her sisters manage to steal the key from Belle, which causes Belle to go back and forth between her house and the castle in trying to find the key, before just running to find the Beast. Lastly, her brother and Avenant climb to the top of the pavilion and break the glass. Avenant tries to lower himself down into the pavilion but is shot by a cupid statue and then just as he turns into a beast, the Beast himself transform into a handsome young prince that sweeps Belle off her feet and carry her away. Also, in the movie, there were most aspects of the Beast showing human qualities, like that part that Ellie already mentioned with him going into her room and hugging her blanket- taking in her smells and her possession as if that was really her. He longed for her and animals don’t usually do that.